This summary does not discuss Contracting Out Agreements (COA) or Relationship Property. If you want to find out about COAs, then read this blog and check out Agreeable.
For this example below:
Ernie and Bert have been together for 10 years and bought a newbuild property together for $600,000. Ernie’s parents want to contribute $120,000 for the 20% deposit.
Ernie and Bert have heard about a Deed of Gift (DOG) and a Deed of Acknowledgement of Debt (DOAD) but are unsure which option is best for them. Here’s a summary of both options:
Bert would have a claim to half of the sale of the property (including half the deposit of $60,000/$120,000) because the money was used to buy Relationship Property.
A DOG should be used where the funds are intended to benefit both Bert and Ernie and all parties understand the money from Ernie’s parents will be considered relationship property.
Ernie and Bert and Ernie’s parents sign a DOAD that records the $120,000 as:
A DOAD should be used if, in the case of a breakup, it is important the money comes back to Ernie’s parents and Bert does not have a claim to it.
Any money received pursuant to a DOAD is a debt owed by Bert and Ernie and therefore (assuming they do not break up and stay together) is less favourable from their joint perspective, as they may have to pay it back in the future.
Conclusion
TL; DR (Too long did not read)
Using a Deed of Gift means any gifted money becomes relationship property. The money becomes relationship property when gifted to them both, or if gifted to Ernie when it is intermingled with a relationship asset (the house).
Using a Deed of Acknowledgement of Debt means any money becomes relationship debt. If it is important that your child’s partner (e.g. Bert) does not have a claim to any money provided then a couple should enter into a Deed of Acknowledgement of Debt or a Contracting Out Agreement.